OpenGov Argumentree: improve decision quality

Big Spender
2mos ago
15 Comments
Rejected
  • Content
  • AI Summary
Reply
Up
Share
Request
5,075KSM
Status
Decision14d
Confirmation2d
Attempts
0
Tally
15.3%Aye
50.0%Threshold
84.7%Nay
Aye
36,307KSM
Nay
200.22KKSM
  • 0.0%
  • 0.0%
  • 0.0%

Threshold

Support(0.04%)
6,566.5KSM
Issuance
15.07MKSM
Votes
Nested
Flattened
Calls
  • Call
  • Metadata
  • Timeline4
  • Votes Bubble
  • Statistics
Comments

Nay, I dont know who you are then the amount of fund in this request for a MVP is too much to me

Reply
Up

Hello, on behalf of the AIWeb3 DAO (the most vibrant Chinese community within the Polkadot ecosystem, with the mission to amplify the voice of the Chinese-speaking community and support Chinese content creators, ensuring it plays a pivotal role in shaping the future of Polkadot), We sincerely invite you to join our Twitter Space which is held every Tuesday at 10 AM (UTC+8) on our official Twitter: https://x.com/aiweb3dao. Please join our Telegram group if you have any questions, English TG group: https://t.me/aiweb3dao_eng and Chinese TG group: https://t.me/aiweb3dao

We will discuss the proposal here: https://x.com/i/spaces/1mrGmMXXEaDGy
Initial thoughts: We are not quite familiar with the team and the contribution of the team to the Kusama eco before, also, we would like to know any feedback from users or any projects that are interested in using this new platform, subsquare, polkassembly had already provided a place for discussion, so what is the unique feature of the new platform. Of course, we will wait for the feedback from the community and make the final decision before voting.

您好,我代表AIWeb3 DAO,这个波卡生态中最具活力的中文社区,旨在放大中文社区的声音,支持中文内容创作者,确保其在塑造波卡未来中发挥重要作用。
我们特地邀请你们参加我们的Twitter空间是每周二上午10点(UTC+8), 在我们的官方推特:https://x.com/aiweb3dao. 。如有任何问题,请加入我们的Telegram讨论:英文Telegram https://t.me/aiweb3dao_eng , 中文 TG group: https://t.me/aiweb3dao。

Reply
Up

I like the idea, thank you for working on it!
Yes the proposal could be improved, but I also think that you need and will need some help to make this a success for all of us!
Also, did you know about https://www.kialo.com? They are doing the same, seem to be based in Berlin, with 50-200 employees (https://www.linkedin.com/company/kialo/).
So we should first consider working with them as an alternative, or at least check if this kind of product is really helping or just creating confusion & overhead, and otherwise take inspiration!

Btw, how can we follow up on this project? If you can create a Github org and repository people could join you there! But you'll have to define the incentives to cooperate or a way to split future funding/grants. This could even be cross-ecosystem, ie. applied to any blockchain with governance. You could even create a DAO to manage this project.. (I know about https://daodao.zone that makes it easy on CosmWasm based blockchain, don't know of a similar tool on Dotsama 🫤)

Edited

Reply
Up

经过AIWeb3 的Twitter Space讨论和社区反馈意见,AIWeb3社区决定反对该提案。以下是社区的主要意见:
对于团队的背景不是很熟悉,也没有来参加我们的推特空间,所以不太了解这个团队
没有看到这个产品对于波卡的opengov能带来什么样的具体改进,特别是对于普通用户参与opengov的吸引力不足

我们每周二北京时间早上10点会在AIWeb3 Twitter Space上讨论Kusama的提案,欢迎大家参与讨论。同时,也欢迎大家直接加入我们的Telegram询问任何问题。如果我们对任何提案表达了赞成,AIWeb3社区也会提供中文社区建设的服务和合作,愿意帮项目方一起建设中文社区,希望波卡生态有更多成功的项目。如果被我们拒绝,也不要灰心,我们欢迎申请人代表来我们的推特space分享提案的亮点,同时也请记住,有很多其他的Kusama DV可能会支持你们的提案。

AIWeb3 Community Feedback on Proposal
After discussions on AIWeb3's Twitter Space and feedback from the community, the AIWeb3 community has decided to NAY the proposal. Below are the main points from the community:
We are not very familiar with the team's background, and they did not participate in our Twitter Space, so we don't know much about them. It’s unclear what specific improvements this product will bring to Polkadot's OpenGov, especially in terms of attracting ordinary users to participate in OpenGov.

If your proposal is rejected, don't be discouraged. We welcome proposers to join our Twitter Space to share the highlights of their proposals. There are also many other Kusama DV who might support your proposal.

Reply
Up

I think it is somewhat redundant with the existing voting system and unnecessary under the current circumstances

Reply
Up