PolkaWorld votes NAY

We recognize that Encointer is a Common Good Parachain on Kusama and that its exploration of Proof of Personhood (PoP) aligns closely with Gavin’s vision—potentially influencing Polkadot’s future security model in the long run.

However, the proposal provides too little detail to see the full picture. Moreover, the current user base (in Nigeria and Tanzania) has not meaningfully entered the broader Polkadot ecosystem and is primarily using Encointer’s own local currencies. In the short term, there’s limited direct impact on DOT, Polkadot mainnet liquidity, or the developer ecosystem.

See full feedback [here](https://southern-manicure-6ee.notion.site/564-Encointer-Retroactive-Proposal-for-Jan-Jun-2025-23aa3c644fba80f3a585e7bdf4fbec27?source=copy_link).

Dear Proposer,

Thank you for your proposal. Our **first** vote on this proposal is **NAY**.

The **Big Spender** track requires **60% quorum** according to our [voting policy v0.2](https://docs.permanence.io/voting_policy/voting_policy_v0.2.html), and any referendum in which the **majority of members vote abstain receives an abstain vote**. This proposal has received **one aye and three nay** votes from **ten available members**, with **one member abstaining**. Below is a summary of our members' comments:

> The voters expressed concerns that the requested funding of 61,592 CHF did not appear to be justified by the benefits delivered. They argued that the project’s social and community impact was unclear and that the value claimed did not match the considerable funds already provided. Some remarked that the proposal seemed to ask too much while not adequately demonstrating tangible outcomes or providing compelling evidence such as local testimonials or multimedia presentations. Although one voter recognized the innovative approach and potential to empower local communities, they ultimately called for a better presentation of impact before any additional funding was approved.

The full discussion can be found in our [internal voting](https://voting.opensquare.io/space/permanence/proposal/QmVZC83Ru5jzmZSU8eeVcdmxrjfUSx2eyLGtQzHGMnpqs2).

Please feel free to contact us through the links below for further discussion.

Kind regards, Permanence DAO Decentralized Voices Cohort IV Delegate 📅 [Book Office Hours](https://cal.com/permanencedao/office-hours) 💬 [Public Telegram](https://t.me/permanencedao) 🌐️ [Web](https://permanence.io) 🐦 [Twitter](https://twitter.com/permanencedao) 🗳️ [Delegate](https://kusama.subsquare.io/user/EicAs5s99x17qZcQzJMiBCfada9rGyEC6njfiBX3j2EPr9W/votes)

Hi, I am casting this comment on behalf of the 🌶 Hungarian Polkadot DAO 🌶:

While we acknowledge Encointer’s legitimacy and consider this proposal well-written and transparent, the Hungarian Polkadot DAO is voting Nay. Our main concern lies in the lack of clear scalability of the project. One of our DAO members pointed out in the Matrix group that the Encointer app’s UI is inadequate, making it impossible to create new communities through the app itself. Instead, users must visit GitHub and manually configure their community using basic coding, which, while not overly complex, is a major barrier for non-technical users. Until this fundamental usability issue is resolved, making community creation accessible to all, we see little chance for meaningful adoption, and therefore cannot support continued Treasury funding.

You can view how the 🌶 Hungarian Polkadot DAO 🌶 evaluated this proposal on our public page [here](https://polkadothungarydao.notion.site/564-234431027d5b81b397fec491caa38275).

Encointer has continued to deliver on a lean budget and requests retroactive funding for the first half of 2025.

[Full Proposal](https://docs.google.com/document/d/12FzLS1Vi1ig8XTb5-LPP-1bFsMvGoet0U6-cwTLxFkg)

The amount of the proposed spend is **61’592 CHF ≃ 76’713 USD for 6 mt**

Main achievements:

* New local community "PayNuq" bootstrapped in Zaria, Nigeria
* Steady growth of Nyota to >100 active reputables and&#x20;
  * mchezo lending groups among businesses show economic impact
* Established democratic community treasury spending decisions in Nyota and PayNuq communities



Malik on AAG #251, explaining the main achievements in 2025 for far

[https://x.com/TheKusamarian/status/1947567295225889106](https://x.com/TheKusamarian/status/1947567295225889106)

- Encointer asks for funding for early 2025  
- Total request: 61,592 CHF (~76,713 USD)  
- Started new community "PayNuq" in Nigeria  
- Nyota community grew to over 100 members  
- Businesses in Nyota formed lending groups  
- Communities now vote on treasury spending  
- Leader Malik shared updates in a talk

amount

beneficiary

Executed

Submitted

DecisionStarted

DecisionDepositPlaced

ConfirmStarted

Confirmed

big_spender

Encointer Retroactive Proposal for Jan-Jun 2025

candidates

members

proficients

fellows

senior_fellows

experts

senior_experts

masters

senior_masters

grand_masters

root

whitelisted_caller

wish_for_change

staking_admin

treasurer

lease_admin

fellowship_admin

general_admin

auction_admin

referendum_canceller

referendum_killer

small_tipper

big_tipper

small_spender

medium_spender

Origin for signaling that the network wishes for some change

Able to spend up to 333,333.3333 KSM from the treasury at once

Managing the composition of the fellowship

Able to spend up to 8.3333 KSM from the treasury at once

Able to spend up to 33.3333 KSM from the treasury at once

Able to spend up to 333.3333 KSM from the treasury at once

Able to spend up to 3,333.3333 KSM from the treasury at once

Able to spend up to 33,333.3333 KSM from the treasury at once